The hadith is narrated on the authority of . It describes an incident where two men came to Mu’awiyah, both claiming to have killed Ammar ibn Yasir during battle. Key Content:
The Hadith beautifully balances two principles:
While I was with Muawiyah, two men came to him arguing about the killing of Ammar [bin Yasir]. Each of them claimed, "I killed him."
This hadith, which records a tense exchange between Mu'awiyah and Abdullah ibn Amr following the martyrdom of Ammar, is authentic (sahih) . This is the definitive verdict of the leading editors Ahmad Shakir and Shu'ayb al-Arna'ut, making it a verified and reliable historical and prophetic report. musnad ahmad 6929 verified
: One of the absolute master memorizers of his era, widely deemed Thiqah (completely reliable).
This short statement carries a profound legal and spiritual lesson.
Musnad Ahmad 6929 (also indexed in some editions as 6931) is a verified authentic tradition ( The hadith is narrated on the authority of
. Each man claimed the "honor" of having killed him, presenting his head as proof of his deed. Abdullah ibn Amr ibn al-Aas
"Pardon the punishments ( hudud ) among yourselves, for whatever reaches me of a prescribed punishment, it becomes mandatory to implement." Legal Implications
If you'd like to dive deeper into this historical period, I can: Explain the context of the Battle of Siffin Provide more biographical details on Ammar ibn Yasir Abdullah ibn Amr Share other authenticated narrations regarding the "rebellious group" prophecy Which of these would help you complete your research Aḥmad (أحمد) ahmad:6929 - Ḥadīth Unlocked Each of them claimed, "I killed him
If you see someone claiming this hadith is "weak," they may be looking at an older, uncorrected manuscript or ignoring the principle of shawahid (supporting narrations).
The hadith is graded Sahih (authentic) or Hasan (good) by major scholars, including Al-Albani (in Silsilah al-Ahadith al-Sahihah ) and Shu’ayb al-Arna’ut in his commentary on the Musnad. 💡 Key Takeaways
Upon hearing the prophecy, Muawiyah challenged Abdullah bin Amr's presence in his camp, as the text implicated his faction Hadith Unlocked.